Editorial review · Updated September 2026
MySugarDaddy
MySugarDaddy claims 7 million members and runs a hybrid model — gender-differentiated subscription pricing plus a monthly credit allowance to unlock conversations. Its Trustpilot score (3.1/5 across 746 reviews) is the best of the three most-established brands in this hub, but a real, repeated complaint describes profiles seemingly created to drain credits, deceptive "you have a message" notifications, and denied refunds on monthly subscriptions.
Platform Details
Pros & Cons
+ What works
- ✓User-friendly layout
- ✓Premium sugar dating site
- ✓Large membership base
- ✓Built-in video chat feature
- ✓Free basic features
! What to watch
- •Some users report it as a scam site
- •May have fake or inactive profiles
- •Total rip-off according to some reviews
- •Hidden costs for premium features
Community Consensus
"The most repeated complaint describes profiles seemingly designed to consume paid credits, conversations vanishing mid-exchange, and misleading "new message" email notifications for messages that weren't actually present on login. Secondary complaints describe unclear auto-renewal terms and denied refund requests on monthly subscriptions."
- Trustpilot
- 3.1 / 5
- 746 reviews
No refunds for unused subscription time, typical of major dating apps.
Automatic subscription renewal is common, leading to unwanted payments.
The most Trustpilot-reviewed platform in this hub with the best score among comparable competitors (3.1/5, 746 reviews) — still weighed down by fake-profile-for-credits complaints and refund denials.
MySugarDaddy claims 7 million members and runs a hybrid model — gender-differentiated subscription pricing plus a monthly credit allowance to unlock conversations. Its Trustpilot score (3.1/5 across 746 reviews) is the best of the three most-established brands in this hub, but a real, repeated complaint describes profiles seemingly created to drain credits, deceptive "you have a message" notifications, and denied refunds on monthly subscriptions.
Score breakdown
Scored on niche fit, real community size and activity, verification/scam risk, trust and billing transparency, customer support, and free-tier usability — the same six-category framework used across every review in this hub.
A real, established sugar dating brand with a large, genuine review footprint suggesting real ongoing usage.
7 million members claimed, and a 746-review Trustpilot base is the largest in this hub outside SecretBenefits — a real signal of substantial ongoing traffic.
Multiple reviewers describe profiles that seem designed specifically to consume paid credits rather than lead to real conversations, plus messaging notifications for messages that reviewers say didn't actually exist in their inbox.
Real, gender-differentiated pricing is disclosed, but reviewers report unclear automatic-renewal terms and denied refund requests on monthly subscriptions.
Reviewers describe inconsistent moderation — some suspicious profiles reported to support aren't promptly removed.
Free signup and browsing exist; VIP members additionally receive a monthly credit allowance rather than paying per-action with no allotment at all.
✓ Best For
- •Anyone who wants the platform in this specific comparison set with the strongest independent review base and best score
- •Women specifically, given the meaningfully lower advertised pricing tier for female members
- •Users comfortable with a monthly credit allowance model rather than a flat unlimited-messaging subscription
✕ Not For
- •Anyone who wants zero risk of encountering credit-draining fake profiles — this is a real, repeated complaint theme here
- •Users who might need a refund on a monthly subscription — reviewers report denial as a common outcome
- •Anyone who wants crystal-clear auto-renewal disclosure — reviewers describe it as unclear
What MySugarDaddy Actually Is
MySugarDaddy positions itself as "the world's largest sugar dating community," claiming 7 million members worldwide with active presence across the US and Europe. It runs both a website and a mobile app, with a support infrastructure that includes an imprint, privacy policy, terms, a cancellation policy, and a DSA reporting form — more visible legal documentation than several competitors in this hub provide.
Real Pricing Breakdown
MySugarDaddy prices differently by gender — a real, disclosed structural choice rather than a hidden one — on top of a monthly credit allowance for VIP members.
| Plan | Price and billing | Monthly |
|---|---|---|
| Free | — | Profile, browsing |
| VIP (women) — 1 month | $29.99 · Billed monthly | $29.99/mo |
| VIP (women) — 12 months | From $15.99/mo · Billed annually | $15.99/mo |
| VIP (men) — 1 month | $64.99 · Billed monthly | $64.99/mo |
| VIP (men) — 12 months | From $34.99/mo · Billed annually | $34.99/mo |
The Fake-Profile-for-Credits Complaint
The most repeated theme in MySugarDaddy's Trustpilot reviews describes profiles that appear designed specifically to consume paid credits — conversations that vanish, profiles that get "deleted," "suspended," or "blocked" mid-conversation, and misleading email notifications about new messages that reviewers say weren't actually present in their inbox when they logged in.
This is a distinct, specific pattern worth taking seriously alongside the platform's real scale — a large user base doesn't rule out a real credit-drain problem happening within it.
Ready to see who's active near you?
Try MySugarDaddy Free →What Actual Users Are Saying
MySugarDaddy holds a 3.1-out-of-5 Trustpilot score across 746 reviews — meaningfully better than the other two most-established platforms compared alongside it in this hub, though still reflecting a real, mixed experience rather than a clean record. Complaints beyond the credit-drain pattern focus on unclear automatic-renewal terms and refund requests being denied for monthly subscriptions.
“A 3.1/5 score across 746 reviews is the best Trustpilot record among this hub's largest, most-established brands — real, but still a genuinely mixed one, not a clean pass.”
Frequently asked questions
MySugarDaddy has the strongest independent review base and best score of the largest, most-established sugar dating brands compared in this hub — a real, meaningful data point in its favor. But a specific, repeated fake-profile-for-credits complaint pattern and reviewer-reported refund denials mean "better than its closest peers" shouldn't be mistaken for "clean." Track your credit spending closely and cancel proactively rather than counting on a refund.