Real Editorial Scores — Not a Paid Ranking

The Best
Sugar Dating Sites

We researched pricing, verification, security history, and real Trustpilot and BBB records for 16 sugar dating platforms — every real candidate we could find. 13 made this list; three did not, and we're saying exactly why.

No paid placement Real scores shown (3.7-5.4) 3 platforms excluded, with reasons How we score

Our Picks at a Glance

W
WhatsYourPrice
Anyone who prefers paying only for specific outcomes (an accepted date) over a flat monthly subscription
5.4/10
S
Sugarmeet
iOS users specifically who want the rare reassurance of a large, real App Store rating sample before downloading
5.3/10
S
Sugarbook
Users based in Malaysia, Singapore, or the Philippines, where the platform has its deepest and most active user base
5.2/10
S
Seeking
Anyone who wants the largest, most globally recognized platform in this category by member count
5.2/10
S
Sugardaddie
Anyone who specifically wants the longest-running, most established name in sugar dating rather than a newer app
5.1/10
M
MySugarDaddy
Anyone who wants the platform in this specific comparison set with the strongest independent review base and best score
4.8/10
G
GayArrangement
Gay men specifically looking for a sugar arrangement — this is the only platform in the hub built for that intent directly
4.5/10
S
Secret-Arrangement
Users who want a free-to-join platform built specifically around the sugar arrangement model
4.4/10
S
SugarDaddyForMe
Users who want to try full Premium features briefly via the 3-day free trial before deciding
4.3/10
A
Adult Arrangements
Users who want to see an actual, itemized price list before committing (when the site is charging — see the contradiction noted below)
4.3/10
F
Favor Dating
Users specifically interested in the "elite"/executive dating framing rather than a straightforward transactional-arrangement site
4.2/10
S
SugarDating69
Users who already use one of HubPeople's other branded sites and want to compare the family
3.7/10
S
SugarDaddyMeet
Users who verify the exact, current billed price directly at checkout before committing to any plan length
3.7/10
W

WhatsYourPrice

Editor's Choice

5.4/10 Pay-per-date (from $50/100 credits)
Real tiered ID verification
Best For Anyone who prefers paying only for specific outcomes (an accepted date) over a flat monthly subscription

WhatsYourPrice replaces the usual subscription with a first-date bidding system: "Generous" members offer money for a first date, "Attractive" members accept, reject, or counter. It's run by Reflex Media, Inc. — the same company behind Seeking.com — and has real verification infrastructure (free selfie badge, optional $4.99 ID verification via a third-party service). Its 1.7/5 Trustpilot score across 106 reviews is driven by fake-profile complaints and a credit system reviewers describe as designed to extract payment for non-responses.

1.7★ / 106
Trustpilot
Selfie + $4.99 ID
Verification
Free Tier Selfie Verified (Free) ID Verified ($4.99) Age 18+
S

Sugarmeet

A rare real App Store sample, with a catch

5.3/10 From $12/mo (3-month plan)
8,484 App Store ratings, 4.29★
Best For iOS users specifically who want the rare reassurance of a large, real App Store rating sample before downloading

Sugarmeet is an iOS-only dating app built around two gamified discovery mechanics — a fast swipe-style "Love Bag" mode and a photo-jigsaw-puzzle unlock system — with real, verifiable App Store numbers: 8,484 ratings averaging 4.29 stars. That's a genuinely rare hard-data sample in this category. But an independent NLP safety analysis of those same reviews scores the app just 30.6 out of 100, and specific reviews describe encountering bots and scam artists — a reminder that a high star average and a low underlying trust signal can both be real at once.

4.29★ / 8.5K
App Store
30.6/100
NLP Safety Score
Free Tier Email Age 18+
A high star average and a low independent NLP safety score are both real, from the same review base — specific reviews describe bots and scam artists. iOS-only, no confirmed Android version.
S

Sugarbook

The biggest name in Southeast Asia

5.2/10 $39.95/mo
Free Premium for verified students
Best For Users based in Malaysia, Singapore, or the Philippines, where the platform has its deepest and most active user base

Sugarbook is a real, large platform with genuine brand recognition across Malaysia, Singapore, and the Philippines, plus a distinctive free-Premium program for verified female college students. It was also banned from Google Play in 2019 and is Apple App Store-free entirely, and its founder was arrested and investigated by Malaysian police in 2021 over allegations directly tied to the platform — a serious, documented incident that any honest review has to weigh alongside the platform's real scale.

2.7★ / 35
Trustpilot
SE Asia leader
Region
Free Tier Phone/Facebook Photo (~85% self-reported) Age 18+
Founder Darren Chan was arrested and investigated by Malaysian police in 2021 over allegations tied to the platform — a real, documented event worth knowing before you join, not just marketing controversy.
S

Seeking

The category's flagship brand

5.2/10 $89.99/mo
46M members claimed
Best For Anyone who wants the largest, most globally recognized platform in this category by member count

Seeking (formerly SeekingArrangement) is the platform most people picture when they hear "sugar dating" — claiming 46 million members and run by Reflex Media, Inc., the same company behind WhatsYourPrice. It has real, modern safety infrastructure (ID verification, video chat, AI message monitoring), but its Trustpilot score (1.6/5) and an F rating with the Better Business Bureau are driven by a specific, repeated complaint: accounts suspended right after a paid subscription, with refunds denied.

46M+
Members
1.6★ / 41
Trustpilot
Free Tier ID Verification Video Chat Age 18+
An F-rated BBB profile (41 complaints) and a 1.6★ Trustpilot record are both driven by the same repeated pattern: suspended right after paying, refund denied. Real safety tools exist — pay for the shortest term first.
S

Sugardaddie

The 22-year veteran

5.1/10 From $9.99/mo (annual)
Free members can reply, not just browse
Best For Anyone who specifically wants the longest-running, most established name in sugar dating rather than a newer app

Sugardaddie.com has quietly outlasted most of its early competition, and its free tier is genuinely more usable than most rivals' — free members can browse, search, and reply to messages sent to them, not just look. But there's no mobile app, the design hasn't meaningfully changed in years, and a consistent theme across reviews is a heavy share of fake or scam-driving profiles.

2002
Founded
2.2★ / 9
Trustpilot
Free Tier Email Age 18+
No mobile app, and reviewers report a high share of fake or scam-driving profiles — verify before sending anyone money.
M

MySugarDaddy

Best Trustpilot record among the biggest brands

4.8/10 From $15.99/mo (women, annual)
3.1★ across 746 reviews — the strongest in its class
Best For Anyone who wants the platform in this specific comparison set with the strongest independent review base and best score

MySugarDaddy claims 7 million members and runs a hybrid model — gender-differentiated subscription pricing plus a monthly credit allowance to unlock conversations. Its Trustpilot score (3.1/5 across 746 reviews) is the best of the three most-established brands in this hub, but a real, repeated complaint describes profiles seemingly created to drain credits, deceptive "you have a message" notifications, and denied refunds on monthly subscriptions.

3.1★ / 746
Trustpilot
7M claimed
Members
Free Tier Email Age 18+
A real, repeated complaint describes profiles seemingly designed to drain paid credits, plus reviewer-reported refund denials on monthly subscriptions.
G

GayArrangement

The only gay-specific option in this hub

4.5/10 From $9.99/mo (6-month plan)
Gay sugar dating, specifically, for 10+ years
Best For Gay men specifically looking for a sugar arrangement — this is the only platform in the hub built for that intent directly

GayArrangement fills a genuine gap: it's the only platform in this hub built specifically around gay sugar arrangements, running for over a decade with a claimed 100,000+ members. Pricing is affordable relative to the category ($19.99/month, dropping to an effective $9.99/month on a 6-month plan), but there's no disclosed verification method beyond signup, and — unusually for a platform this size — no Trustpilot presence at all to independently check sentiment against.

100K+
Members
Not listed
Trustpilot
Free Tier Email Age 18+
No disclosed verification beyond signup, and no Trustpilot presence at all — the same information gap as SugarDaddyForMe, just on a gay-specific platform with no real alternative in this hub.
S

Secret-Arrangement

3M members claimed, but no published price list

4.4/10
"Income verified" / "photo verified" badges
Best For Users who want a free-to-join platform built specifically around the sugar arrangement model

Secret-Arrangement.com markets itself around "income verified" sugar daddies and "photo verified" sugar babies, claiming 3 million active members. It's a real, functioning website, but we couldn't find a published pricing page anywhere on the site, it has no Trustpilot presence to check sentiment against, and it shares near-identical branding with several other "secret arrangement"-named domains — worth knowing before you assume you're on the one you meant to visit.

3M claimed
Members
Not listed
Trustpilot
Free Tier Claimed income/photo verification (unconfirmed) Age 18+
We could not find a published pricing page anywhere on the site, and several near-identically-branded competing domains exist — confirm you're on secret-arrangement.com specifically.
S

SugarDaddyForMe

Try full access free for 3 days

4.3/10 $39.95/mo
3-day free trial
Best For Users who want to try full Premium features briefly via the 3-day free trial before deciding

SugarDaddyForMe claims 4 million members and has been around long enough to be a familiar name in the category, but it's the thinnest-verified platform in this batch: no Trustpilot presence at all, a 1.6/5 rating on complaint boards, and a specific, repeated pattern of free-trial signups turning into unexpected recurring charges that are then hard to refund.

4M+
Members
Not listed
Trustpilot
Free Tier Email Age 18+
No Trustpilot presence at all despite the claimed 4M members, plus a repeated free-trial-into-surprise-billing complaint — track your cancellation date closely.
A

Adult Arrangements

Itemized pricing, with an unresolved contradiction

4.3/10
"Hot Dates" feed with real $ amounts attached
Best For Users who want to see an actual, itemized price list before committing (when the site is charging — see the contradiction noted below)

Adult Arrangements is a live, functioning site built around a "Hot Dates" feature where members post specific arrangements with real monetary amounts attached. Its Premium/Gold/Diamond tiers (priced in AUD, up to $200 AUD/month) are more transparently disclosed than several other platforms in this hub — but its own Terms page separately states the site "is currently 100% free," directly contradicting the paid tiers listed on its own membership page. There's no Trustpilot presence and no independent complaint data to check against either claim.

$200 AUD/mo (Diamond)
Top Tier
Not listed
Trustpilot
Free Tier Profile Approval Age 18+
The site's own Terms page claims it's "currently 100% free," directly contradicting the paid tiers on its membership page — confirm actual pricing before paying anything. No Trustpilot presence exists.
F

Favor Dating

Elite/executive framing, no published price

4.2/10
100K+ "Elite Members" claimed
Best For Users specifically interested in the "elite"/executive dating framing rather than a straightforward transactional-arrangement site

Favor Dating positions itself around "high-net-worth individuals" and elite companionship, claiming 100,000+ members across 50+ countries and an AI-supported identity verification process. It's a real, functioning website with its own blog content — but we couldn't find a published pricing page anywhere on the site, there's no Trustpilot presence to check independent sentiment against, and its copyright footer credits "Acadecraft Private Limited," a real but unrelated eLearning company, with no independent source confirming why.

100K+ claimed
Members
Not listed
Trustpilot
Free Tier AI-supported (claimed, unconfirmed) Age 18+
No published pricing found anywhere on the site, no Trustpilot presence, and an unexplained footer credit to an unrelated eLearning company (Acadecraft) with no confirmed connection to the platform.
S

SugarDating69

Part of a disclosed sister-site network

3.7/10
"3.7★" Trustpilot — from a single 2016 review
Best For Users who already use one of HubPeople's other branded sites and want to compare the family

SugarDating69 is live and operated by HubPeople, which runs a visible family of near-identically-templated sites (BBWDating69, CasualDating69, Cougars69, Swingers69, Vanessa69). Its Trustpilot page shows a 3.7-out-of-5 score, but that figure comes from a single review posted in 2016 — zero reviews have been submitted in the last 12 months, which means the headline number is technically real but practically meaningless as a current trust signal.

HubPeople network
Operator
3.7★ / 1 (2016)
Trustpilot
Free Tier Email Age 18+
The Trustpilot score shown is built on exactly one review from 2016, with zero reviews in the last 12 months — a technically real but practically meaningless current trust signal. No pricing is published anywhere on the site.
S

SugarDaddyMeet

A real operator, a real price-inflation complaint

3.7/10 From $24/mo (6-month plan)
Advertised $50-144, reviewers report $160+/mo billed
Best For Users who verify the exact, current billed price directly at checkout before committing to any plan length

SugarDaddyMeet advertises straightforward tiered pricing ($50–$144 depending on term length) and free signup, operated by the real, traceable Successfulmatch.Com, Inc. But its 1.6/5 Trustpilot score across 69 reviews centers on a specific, repeated complaint: members report actual charges landing at $160+/month, roughly three times the advertised rate, on top of widespread reports of bot profiles (some reviewers estimate 80–90% of activity) and payment-scam allegations between members.

1.6★ / 69
Trustpilot
Successfulmatch.Com, Inc.
Operator
Free Tier Email Age 18+
The single most repeated complaint describes actual billed charges landing roughly triple the advertised price, alongside multiple reviewer estimates that 80-90% of activity is bot-driven.

Which One Fits You?

I want the most built-out identity verification WhatsYourPrice
I'm in Southeast Asia specifically Sugarbook
I want the biggest, most recognized brand name Seeking
I want free members to actually be able to reply Sugardaddie
I want to test the platform free before paying SugarDaddyForMe
I'm a gay man looking for a sugar arrangement GayArrangement
I want income/photo verification claims, even if unconfirmed Secret-Arrangement
I want the "elite/executive" framing over a plain arrangement site Favor Dating
I want the reassurance of a large, real App Store rating sample Sugarmeet
I want the best Trustpilot record among the biggest, most established brands MySugarDaddy

Side by Side

Site Score Best For Price Free Tier Signature Feature
WhatsYourPrice 5.4/10 Anyone who prefers paying only for specific outcomes (an accepted date) over a flat monthly subscription Pay-per-date (from $50/100 credits) ✓ Real tiered ID verification
Sugarmeet 5.3/10 iOS users specifically who want the rare reassurance of a large, real App Store rating sample before downloading From $12/mo (3-month plan) ✓ 8,484 App Store ratings, 4.29★
Sugarbook 5.2/10 Users based in Malaysia, Singapore, or the Philippines, where the platform has its deepest and most active user base $39.95/mo ✓ Free Premium for verified students
Seeking 5.2/10 Anyone who wants the largest, most globally recognized platform in this category by member count $89.99/mo ✓ 46M members claimed
Sugardaddie 5.1/10 Anyone who specifically wants the longest-running, most established name in sugar dating rather than a newer app From $9.99/mo (annual) ✓ Free members can reply, not just browse
MySugarDaddy 4.8/10 Anyone who wants the platform in this specific comparison set with the strongest independent review base and best score From $15.99/mo (women, annual) ✓ 3.1★ across 746 reviews — the strongest in its class
GayArrangement 4.5/10 Gay men specifically looking for a sugar arrangement — this is the only platform in the hub built for that intent directly From $9.99/mo (6-month plan) ✓ Gay sugar dating, specifically, for 10+ years
Secret-Arrangement 4.4/10 Users who want a free-to-join platform built specifically around the sugar arrangement model Free ✓ "Income verified" / "photo verified" badges
SugarDaddyForMe 4.3/10 Users who want to try full Premium features briefly via the 3-day free trial before deciding $39.95/mo ✓ 3-day free trial
Adult Arrangements 4.3/10 Users who want to see an actual, itemized price list before committing (when the site is charging — see the contradiction noted below) Free ✓ "Hot Dates" feed with real $ amounts attached
Favor Dating 4.2/10 Users specifically interested in the "elite"/executive dating framing rather than a straightforward transactional-arrangement site Free ✓ 100K+ "Elite Members" claimed
SugarDating69 3.7/10 Users who already use one of HubPeople's other branded sites and want to compare the family Free ✓ "3.7★" Trustpilot — from a single 2016 review
SugarDaddyMeet 3.7/10 Users who verify the exact, current billed price directly at checkout before committing to any plan length From $24/mo (6-month plan) ✓ Advertised $50-144, reviewers report $160+/mo billed

Common Questions

What is the best sugar dating site right now?

WhatsYourPrice has the most genuinely built-out verification system (a free Selfie Verified badge plus an optional $4.99 ID check) alongside a real pay-per-date model instead of a flat subscription. Sugarmeet has the rarest hard signal — 8,484 real App Store ratings — though with a real, disclosed scam-complaint pattern underneath. Sugarbook has the biggest real brand recognition in Southeast Asia and a free Premium program for verified students. Seeking is the category's flagship by sheer size. MySugarDaddy has the best Trustpilot record among the biggest, most-established brands. Sugardaddie is the longest-running name and lets free members actually reply to messages. SugarDaddyForMe offers the most generous free trial. GayArrangement is the only gay-specific option with real signal. The remaining picks (Secret-Arrangement, Favor Dating, SugarDating69, Adult Arrangements, SugarDaddyMeet) all carry real, disclosed transparency or billing concerns — read the individual review before choosing one of these. We picked each for a specific, named reason, not a 1-through-13 ranking.

Why isn't there a platform on this list scoring above 5.4?

Because we're reporting real numbers, not flattering ones. Every platform in this category we've researched carries a genuine, documented trust problem of some kind — fake-profile complaints, a rough Trustpilot or BBB record, a real 2021 legal incident involving Sugarbook's founder, a low independent NLP safety score underneath a high star average (Sugarmeet), an unresolved pricing contradiction (Adult Arrangements), a repeated price-inflation complaint (SugarDaddyMeet), or simply no independent review presence at all to check against (GayArrangement, Secret-Arrangement, Favor Dating). We'd rather show an honest 3.7–5.4 range than round everyone up to look better than the research actually supports.

Why aren't HePays, PayMeDaddy, and Secret Benefits on this list?

Because all three have a real, serious trust problem we're not comfortable recommending past. HePays' only paid tier is a Bitcoin-only lifetime fee (effectively impossible to dispute), its free path requires leaving the platform to join an external Telegram group for "verification," and multiple independent sources describe the site repeatedly shutting down and keeping members' unused credits when it reopens (scored 3.1/10). PayMeDaddy has a specific, documented Trustpilot complaint describing an $18 advertised promotion resulting in a $224 charge, alongside repeated fake-profile reports and a refused refund claim (scored 3.4/10). Secret Benefits carries the largest independent review sample in this entire hub (978 Trustpilot reviews) and its most severe score (1.6/5), driven by a specific, repeated bait-and-switch pattern where paid interest evaporates immediately after credits are purchased (scored 3.2/10). We reviewed and scored all three for completeness, but none appears on this list.

Is sugar dating safe?

Verification quality varies a lot across this category, and arrangements often move toward meeting in person quickly. WhatsYourPrice and Seeking both offer real, if optional, identity verification tools worth using; GayArrangement, Secret-Arrangement, Favor Dating, SugarDating69, Adult Arrangements, and SugarDaddyMeet all disclose no independently confirmed verification beyond basic signup, so extra caution applies to those six. Sugarmeet discloses only email/age verification, and its own review base carries a specific, documented scam-complaint pattern. Before meeting anyone, our Safety Hub covers reverse-image search and background-check tools that work independently of whatever a platform itself claims to verify.

Is this list complete?

We've now deep-reviewed every real candidate we surfaced for this category — 16 total, 13 of which made this list. We'll keep adding to it if new real candidates turn up.

Is there a free sugar dating site?

All thirteen platforms here have a real, functional free tier. Sugardaddie stands out specifically because free members can reply to messages sent to them, not just browse — most competitors gate replies entirely behind a paid tier. WhatsYourPrice is free to receive and negotiate offers if you're on the receiving side. Sugarmeet gives free users a chat unlock after completing 5 in-app puzzles.

How We Actually Picked These

Each platform on this list has its own full editorial review — pricing pages, Trustpilot and BBB records fetched directly, cross-checked against what each platform's own marketing claims. That's a research-based process, not hands-on testing — see our methodology for exactly what that distinction means.

We've now deep-reviewed every real candidate we surfaced for this category — 16 in total. We'll keep adding to this list if new real candidates turn up.

Three platforms we researched had real trust problems serious enough to leave off this list entirely. HePays' only paid option is a Bitcoin-only lifetime fee (effectively impossible to dispute), its free path requires leaving the platform to join an external Telegram group for "verification," and multiple independent sources describe the site shutting down and reopening while keeping members' unused credits. PayMeDaddy has a specific, documented Trustpilot complaint describing an $18 advertised promotion resulting in a $224 charge, on top of repeated fake-profile reports and a refused refund claim. Secret Benefits carries the largest independent review sample in this entire hub (978 Trustpilot reviews) and the most severe score (1.6/5) — driven by a specific, repeated bait-and-switch pattern where paid interest evaporates immediately after credits are purchased. We reviewed all three for completeness and scored them accordingly — none of them is here.

16
Real candidates identified
16
Deep-reviewed so far
13
Cleared the bar for this list

Two well-known brands we specifically checked — MissTravel and RichMeetBeautiful — turned out to have shut down entirely, confirmed directly on their own (now defunct) homepages. We left both out rather than reviewing a dead platform.