Editorial review · Updated September 2026
PositiveSingles
PositiveSingles (positivesingles.com), run by SuccessfulMatch since 2001, is the biggest name in this hub by a wide margin — 2M+ claimed members, a 4.3★ App Store rating from 7,600+ ratings, and 24 years of operating history. But its Trustpilot page tells a rougher story: 1.7/5 from fake-profile, gender-imbalance, and billing complaints, plus a 2025 privacy-related lawsuit. Scale is real. So are the complaints.
Platform Details
Pros & Cons
+ What works
- ✓Large, diverse STI-positive community and wide geographic coverage
- ✓Judgment-free, privacy-focused, and supportive environment
- ✓Free tier includes browsing, likes/winks, commenting, blogs/Moments, and community access
- ✓Video and voice calling available
- ✓Verified profiles and support resources
! What to watch
- •Some communication features require premium membership
- •Results depend on your location and activity level
- •Some users report shady business practices and describe it as a money pit/scam
- •Premium membership is needed for the best experience; free communication is limited
- •Reddit users report very few paid matches in some large cities such as NYC
Community Consensus
"Reddit feedback is mixed: some users appreciate the niche community and upfront HSV disclosure, while others complain about very few matches even in large cities and question whether paying is worth it. Some prefer using regular dating apps and disclosing early."
- Trustpilot
- 1.7 / 5
- 21 reviews
- App Store
- 4.3 / 5
- 7 600 ratings
- Company
- PositiveSingles
- Based in
- Canada
- Typical age
- 25-34
Refund and billing policy is available; includes subscription management, cancellation, and consumer protection rights (see https://www.positivesingles.app/help/refund/).
Official membership/billing policy explains payments, renewals, and cancellations; no exact auto-renewal wording was provided (see https://www.positivesingles.app/help/membership/).
The largest, longest-running STD dating site — real scale and real App Store numbers, undercut by a genuinely bad Trustpilot record.
PositiveSingles (positivesingles.com), run by SuccessfulMatch since 2001, is the biggest name in this hub by a wide margin — 2M+ claimed members, a 4.3★ App Store rating from 7,600+ ratings, and 24 years of operating history. But its Trustpilot page tells a rougher story: 1.7/5 from fake-profile, gender-imbalance, and billing complaints, plus a 2025 privacy-related lawsuit. Scale is real. So are the complaints.
Score breakdown
Weighted toward verified scale and feature depth, but with real weight given to independent trust signals — a platform this large carrying a 1.7/5 Trustpilot score can't be scored as if that data didn't exist, even alongside a strong App Store number.
2M+ claimed members, 24 years of operating history, and an App Store rating built on 7,600+ ratings — the largest verified footprint in this hub.
1.7/5 on Trustpilot (21 reviews): fake-profile complaints, a reported ~5:1 male-to-female skew, and manipulative-upsell accusations. A 2025 privacy-related lawsuit adds to the concern.
Video/voice calling, community blogs and forums, and a broad free tier (browsing, likes, comments, community posts) ahead of most competitors in this hub.
Real, published tiers exist on both web and app, but in-app pricing ($33.99–$109.99) runs notably higher than the web pricing SuccessfulMatch publishes elsewhere ($15.99–$29.95/mo equivalent).
Email and age verification only — no ID or photo requirement, and Trustpilot reviewers specifically flag fake profiles as a recurring problem.
Profile building, browsing, likes/winks, commenting, and community posting are free; real two-way messaging requires premium.
✓ Best For
- •Anyone who wants the largest, most established STD/HIV dating community rather than a smaller newer app
- •Users who value video and voice calling as part of the platform, not just text messaging
- •People comfortable weighing a strong App Store rating against a much rougher independent Trustpilot record
- •Women — the site’s own reported gender split (68.97% male / 31.03% female) means men face real competition for attention
✕ Not For
- •Anyone who wants ID or photo verification before trusting that a profile is real
- •Users put off by a documented pattern of fake-profile and billing complaints on Trustpilot
- •People who want in-app pricing to match the lower web pricing SuccessfulMatch advertises elsewhere
- •Men in markets with a heavy male skew — Reddit threads specifically describe very few matches in some large cities
What PositiveSingles Actually Is
PositiveSingles is the flagship product of SuccessfulMatch.com, Inc., a Vaughan, Ontario-based company that's been running STD-focused dating sites since 2001. It's built around a simple premise: a dating platform where an HSV, HIV, HPV, or hepatitis diagnosis doesn't have to be a disclosure conversation, because it's assumed context rather than a surprise. SuccessfulMatch reports over 2 million members and 24+ years of operating history — the deepest track record of anything in this hub.
The platform sits at the center of a small network of sister brands under the same parent company, including MPWH (herpes-specific) and HSVSingles (operated under license) — all reviewed separately in this guide, since each has its own distinct positioning, pricing, and trust record despite the shared ownership.
Real Pricing Breakdown
Pricing varies meaningfully depending on where you subscribe. The iOS in-app purchase listing shows notably higher prices than the web-published rates — a gap worth knowing about before you pick a signup path.
| Plan | Price and billing | Monthly |
|---|---|---|
| Free | — | Browsing, likes, comments, community access |
| Web — 1 month | $29.95 · Billed monthly | $29.95/mo |
| Web — 3 months | $59.94 · Billed every 3 months | ~$19.98/mo |
| Web — 6 months | $95.94 · Billed every 6 months | ~$15.99/mo |
| iOS App — 1 month | $33.99 · Via Apple in-app purchase | $33.99/mo |
| iOS App — 6 months | $109.99 · Via Apple in-app purchase | ~$18.33/mo |
Trustpilot vs. App Store — Two Very Different Pictures
This is the review's central tension. PositiveSingles' App Store rating sits at a strong 4.3 out of 5 across 7,600+ ratings. Its Trustpilot page, fetched directly, shows a very different 1.7 out of 5 from 21 reviews — with recurring themes: reviewers describing roughly one in four profiles as fake, a reported gender imbalance around five men for every woman, difficulty messaging anyone without paying, and accusations that the platform shows out-of-area likes to pressure a subscription upgrade despite location filters being set.
A 2025 privacy-related lawsuit against the platform adds further weight to the trust question, on a platform where the underlying data being protected is uniquely sensitive — health status. We couldn't independently verify the lawsuit's outcome at review time, but its existence is a real, citable fact worth knowing before you sign up.
Neither number tells the whole story alone. A 7,600-rating App Store sample is large enough to mean something; so is a documented, specific complaint pattern on Trustpilot, even from a comparatively small sample of 21 reviews. Read both.
Ready to see who's active near you?
Try PositiveSingles Free →Verification, Privacy & the Catfish Question
Verification is limited to email and self-reported age — there's no ID or photo verification requirement, which lines up with the fake-profile complaints on Trustpilot. Treat any promising match with the same caution you'd apply anywhere: reverse-image search photos, and use a video call before agreeing to meet.
Given the platform centers on health-status disclosure, the practical privacy stakes are higher than on a typical dating app — a compromised or fake account here can expose more than a name and a photo. That raises the bar for what "good enough" verification should look like, and PositiveSingles' current setup doesn't clear it.
What Actual Users Are Saying
Reddit sentiment (r/HSVpositive) is genuinely mixed rather than uniformly negative — some users specifically appreciate the niche community and the ability to disclose upfront rather than mid-conversation on a mainstream app. Others report very few real matches even in large cities like New York, and question whether the premium cost is worth it relative to just disclosing early on a general dating app.
One notable, specific pattern from Trustpilot: a reviewer questioned the authenticity of the platform's own five-star reviews, suggesting some may be inauthentic — worth factoring in when weighing any single review platform's score in isolation.
Frequently asked questions
PositiveSingles earns its position as the default starting point for this category on scale alone — 2M+ members, 24 years running, and a 4.3★ App Store rating nothing else here can match. But a 1.7/5 Trustpilot score with a specific, recurring complaint pattern (fake profiles, gender imbalance, billing pressure) plus a 2025 privacy lawsuit are real facts that keep this from an easy top score. Go in with eyes open: subscribe via the web for better pricing, and don't skip the usual verification precautions.