Editor's Review Married & Discreet Hub Affair Dating Affair Dating

FirstAffair

FirstAffair is a German-market affair dating site with genuinely published, specific pricing (from about $8.33/mo). Its Trustpilot page shows only 5 total reviews — all one-star — describing roughly 90% fake profiles and an inactive user base. That's a genuinely thin sample, but every single data point available points the same direction.

Full platform description

First Affair operates as an affair-focused dating platform serving German-speaking markets across Germany, Austria, and Switzerland. The service connects individuals seeking discreet erotic encounters, affairs, and partner-swapping arrangements. Registration requires only an email address, with the platform emphasizing complete anonymity and minimal personal data collection. The site accepts users aged 18 to 99 and allows filtering by location across its supported countries. The pricing model differentiates by gender: women receive complimentary full membership when seeking men or couples, while men pay from 8.33 EUR monthly for premium access. The free tier provides substantial functionality including profile creation and browsing, message reception from interested members, ignore lists, online status visibility, and profile visitor tracking. The only restriction in the free tier is the inability to initiate contact with other members. Premium membership unlocks outbound messaging capabilities and other contact features. User profiles support up to ten photographs and detailed preference information. The platform includes standard features such as a trust list for managing connections, comprehensive search filters, and an internal messaging system. According to press materials, the site processes approximately 1,000 new registrations daily and reports a cumulative membership base exceeding 2.1 million users since its April 2004 launch. The active user demographic skews approximately 75% male and 25% female. A mobile-optimized website is available, though no dedicated mobile application is mentioned in the available materials.

Editor score 4.6 / 10
Price from $8.33/mo Free tier available
Members (est.) 25K+ View source
Trustpilot 2.5 ★ 5 reviews

Platform Details

Hookup-friendly ✓ Email Verified✓ Email Verification✓ Age Verification (18+) Network: null

Pros & Cons

+ What works

  • ✓Matching tool can pair users with partners or at least good friends
  • ✓Can be a helpful tool for finding a casual fling or long-term partner
  • ✓Provides a niche for affair dating with comparison options against similar platforms

! What to watch

  • •Review context suggests users have figured out which dating sites are better than firstaffair.com
  • •Affair dating platforms can expose your profile to witnesses who may tell your partner about your online activity
  • •Dating apps are not for everyone and carry various drawbacks

Community Consensus

Reddit Summary

"One Reddit user said they found First Affair by accident and were glad they did, enjoying the matching tool because it paired them with women who became partners or at least good friends. Broader Reddit discussions about dating apps are mixed, with users asking whether dating apps are worth it and testing multiple apps; there is very little FirstAffair-specific Reddit review coverage."

Trustpilot
2.5 / 5
5 reviews
Based in
Germany
Typical age
18-99
Refund Policy

To cancel your subscription, you must give at least five working days notice prior to the contract expiration date. If you made a purchase through Apple or Google, contact them directly for refund or cancellation. Refunds are reviewed at each platform's discretion.

Auto-Renewal

Memberships will be renewed automatically for the chosen contract period.

The BestPolyDating editorial review

A real German affair-dating brand with published pricing — but its Trustpilot listing is unclaimed, nearly reviewless, and what little feedback exists is uniformly negative.

FirstAffair is a German-market affair dating site with genuinely published, specific pricing (from about $8.33/mo). Its Trustpilot page shows only 5 total reviews — all one-star — describing roughly 90% fake profiles and an inactive user base. That's a genuinely thin sample, but every single data point available points the same direction.

4.6
out of 10, editorial score
Visit FirstAffair
This is a research-based editorial analysis — built from public pricing pages, App Store & Play Store data, security disclosures, and aggregated Reddit/Trustpilot sentiment. It is not a hands-on test (we did not create an account or exchange messages). See our full methodology for what that distinction means.

Score breakdown

Scored with real weight given to the thinness of the trust sample (5 reviews isn't statistically strong either way) balanced against the fact that 100% of that thin sample, plus independent German-language reviewer commentary, point to the same specific complaint (fake profiles, inactivity) rather than mixed signals.

Pricing Transparency 7.0

Real, specific published tiers (~$8.33/mo up to $86.34 for 6 months) — more transparent than several competitors in this hub that publish no pricing at all.

Trust & Reputation Signals 2.5

Only 5 Trustpilot reviews exist, all one-star, unclaimed listing — a thin but unanimously negative sample describing ~90% fake profiles.

Community Activity 3.0

German-language reviewer commentary specifically describes the platform as having become inactive over time, a decline from its earlier reputation.

Operating History 6.0

A real, established German-market brand with enough history that reviewers reference "the service being better a decade ago" — implying genuine longevity, even in decline.

Support Responsiveness 3.0

One reviewer reported sending a bank-transfer payment with no account activation and no response to follow-up — a serious, specific support failure.

✓ Best For

  • •German-market users specifically — this is a genuinely established brand in that market, even if in apparent decline
  • •Anyone who values seeing real, specific published pricing over a platform that hides costs entirely

✕ Not For

  • •Anyone who wants an actively reviewed platform with a meaningful trust sample — only 5 total Trustpilot reviews exist
  • •Users who want confirmation of an active, engaged member base — reviewer commentary specifically describes decline
  • •Anyone planning to pay via bank transfer — one reviewer reported no account activation after doing so
01

What FirstAffair Actually Is

FirstAffair is a German-market affair-dating platform with real, specific published pricing — a genuine transparency advantage over several competitors in this hub that disclose no pricing at all. Tiers run from roughly $8.33/month up to $86.34 for a 6-month plan.

02

A Thin But Unanimous Trust Signal

FirstAffair's Trustpilot page shows a 2.5 out of 5 rating, but that number comes from just 5 total reviews — a genuinely thin sample that can't carry the same statistical weight as, say, Ashley Madison's 639-review record. What's notable is that all 5 are one-star, and the listing remains unclaimed by the company.

German-language reviewer commentary found independently echoes the same specific complaints: roughly "9 von 10 Profilen sind Fake" (9 out of 10 profiles are fake), scammers building false rapport before requesting money, and a general sense among longer-term reviewers that the platform "kaum noch Menschen u nutzen" (hardly has active users anymore) compared to a decade ago. One reviewer specifically reported paying via bank transfer and receiving no account activation, with no response to follow-up.

The thinness of the Trustpilot sample means we can't treat this with the same statistical confidence as platforms with hundreds of reviews — but the fact that every available data point, thin as it is, points the same direction is itself worth taking seriously.

Frequently asked questions

Is FirstAffair still active?

Independent German-language reviewer commentary specifically describes declining activity compared to the platform's earlier years — worth checking real local activity via the free tier before subscribing.

How much does FirstAffair cost?

Published pricing starts around $8.33/month, up to $86.34 for a 6-month plan — genuinely transparent compared to several competitors that disclose no pricing.

Are there fake profiles on FirstAffair?

Reviewer commentary specifically cites a high fake-profile rate ("9 out of 10" per one detailed review) — a thin sample overall, but a consistent complaint across the data available.

Bottom line

FirstAffair is a real, established German-market brand with genuinely transparent pricing — a real point in its favor. But its trust data, though thin (only 5 Trustpilot reviews), is unanimously negative, and independent reviewer commentary consistently describes a declining, increasingly inactive user base. Weigh the thinness of the sample against its consistency before committing.

Visit FirstAffair → BestPolyDating Editorial Team · Updated September 2026
Visit FirstAffair — Free to Join →