Editorial review · Updated September 2026
IamNaughty
IamNaughty is operated by IDALIA LIMITED — the exact same Dublin-based company confirmed to run BeNaughty, already reviewed in this hub. It carries a real 2.1/5 Trustpilot score from 151 reviews, with 'fake AI bots, no real people' as a specific recurring complaint. The one we can't soften: multiple independent reports describe the account-deletion option redirecting to a billing page instead of actually closing the account.
Platform Details
Pros & Cons
+ What works
- ✓Confirmed operated by the exact same legal entity (IDALIA LIMITED, same Dublin address) as BeNaughty, already reviewed in this hub
- ✓Real published pricing rates, no independently confirmed data breach
- ✓Same granular LGBTQ role-selection options as BeNaughty for gay male matching
! What to watch
- •Real, sizeable Trustpilot signal: 2.1/5 from 151 reviews, with "fake AI bots, no real people" as a specific recurring theme
- •A serious, specific complaint pattern around account deletion: multiple users describe the "remove account" option redirecting to billing information instead of actually closing the account
- •Free tier is marketed as including chat, but independent reviews describe a paywall that prevents meaningful use
- •Corporate structure is only partly resolved: legal terms confirm IDALIA LIMITED as operator (same as BeNaughty), while scraped data separately lists "Bulova Invest Ltd" as parent — we couldn't fully reconcile the two
Community Consensus
"I idiotically signed up for iamnaughty.com following a link from a reddit user only to find out how big of a scam it is. I feel like an idiot. I've been trying for the last hour to remove all my info but I am getting sent in circles. The 'remove account' button on the site just brings up a message telling you to look at billing info."
- Trustpilot
- 2.1 / 5
- 151 reviews
- Company
- IDALIA LIMITED
- Based in
- Ireland
- Typical age
- 18-78
You need to cancel your paid membership a minimum 3 days before your renewal date. If you bought a membership using iPhone through iTunes, you need to see the auto-renew cancelation period.
You need to cancel your paid membership a minimum 3 days before your renewal date. If you bought a membership using iPhone through iTunes, you need to see the auto-renew cancelation period.
BeNaughty's sister site, run by the same company — with a specific, credible account-deletion complaint worth knowing before you sign up.
IamNaughty is operated by IDALIA LIMITED — the exact same Dublin-based company confirmed to run BeNaughty, already reviewed in this hub. It carries a real 2.1/5 Trustpilot score from 151 reviews, with 'fake AI bots, no real people' as a specific recurring complaint. The one we can't soften: multiple independent reports describe the account-deletion option redirecting to a billing page instead of actually closing the account.
Score breakdown
We credit confirmed corporate transparency and real published pricing. But a sizeable, current Trustpilot sample with a specific bot complaint, plus a credible and repeated account-deletion dark-pattern report, weigh heavily against it.
Explicit "naughty" hookup framing, sharing the same granular LGBTQ role-selection options as sister brand BeNaughty.
No member count or App Store/Play Store data independently available.
2.1/5 from 151 reviews — a real, sizeable sample — with 'fake AI bots, no real people' as a specific recurring theme.
No independently confirmed data breach found.
Marketed as including chat, but reviews describe a paywall that prevents meaningful use.
Real published rates exist, but a credible, repeated account-deletion complaint is a serious fairness issue independent of the price itself.
✓ Best For
- •People who already know and are comfortable with sister brand BeNaughty's model and want to try a related platform
- •Users who want confirmed, transparent corporate ownership before signing up — IamNaughty's is genuinely confirmed
- •Anyone specifically looking for the same granular LGBTQ role-selection options found on BeNaughty
- •People who weigh a clean breach history — no confirmed incident found here
✕ Not For
- •Anyone who might want to delete their account later — multiple credible reports describe the deletion option redirecting to billing instead of actually closing the account
- •Users hoping free chat works as marketed — reviews describe a paywall blocking real use
- •People who weight current Trustpilot reputation heavily — 2.1/5 from a real 151-review sample is a meaningful signal
- •Anyone who's already had a negative experience with sister brand BeNaughty and is hoping for something different here
What IamNaughty Actually Is
IamNaughty is operated by IDALIA LIMITED — the exact same Irish company, at the exact same Dublin address, confirmed to run BeNaughty, which we've already reviewed in this hub. That's a solid, verifiable corporate connection, not a guess based on shared branding style. BeNaughty's trademark is separately held by Together Networks Holdings Limited, which suggests IDALIA LIMITED functions as an operating subsidiary within that wider network, though we couldn't fully confirm the exact legal relationship between the two entities.
The product itself closely mirrors BeNaughty: casual, adventurous-singles framing, support for heterosexual and same-sex matching, and the same specific role-selection options (Top, Versatile, Bottom, Versatop, Versabottom) for gay male users — consistent with a shared underlying platform template across whatever wider network operates both brands.
Real Pricing Breakdown
IamNaughty's own published rates show a 1-week option at $19.99, a full month at $39.99, and a 3-month plan working out to roughly $23.33/month. The free tier is marketed as including sign-up, browsing, and chatting with matches — but as with several platforms in this hub, independent reviews describe meaningful chat as effectively paywalled once you try to use it for real.
| Plan | Price and billing | Monthly |
|---|---|---|
| Free | — | Browse & profile; chat reportedly paywall-restricted |
| 1 Week | $19.99 · Billed weekly | ~$19.99/wk |
| 1 Month | $39.99 · Billed monthly | $39.99/mo |
| 3 Months | ~$69.99 · Billed every 3 months | ~$23.33/mo |
A Specific, Credible Complaint Worth Taking Seriously
A live Trustpilot check found IamNaughty at 2.1 out of 5 from 151 reviews — a real, sizeable sample, not a handful of outliers. The most specific recurring complaint describes profiles as 'fake AI bots, no real people,' with photos reportedly pulled from adult content elsewhere rather than genuine members. Billing complaints follow a familiar pattern: charges continuing after a cancellation attempt, and difficulty locating a working cancellation path.
One detailed, first-person account we found (shared after a user said they signed up via a link posted by another Reddit user) described exactly this: trying repeatedly to remove their account information, only to have the 'remove account' button redirect to a page showing billing information instead of actually processing a deletion. We're including this because it's specific and detailed rather than a vague complaint, and it matches the broader pattern Trustpilot reviewers describe independently. If you sign up, we'd treat account deletion the same way you'd treat cancelling a hard-to-cancel subscription anywhere: document every step, and dispute the charge with your card issuer directly if the platform's own process doesn't work.
Ready to see who's active near you?
Try IamNaughty Free →Frequently asked questions
IamNaughty's corporate ownership is genuinely confirmed and transparent — the same company that runs BeNaughty — which is more than we can say for several platforms in this hub. But a real, sizeable Trustpilot sample pointing to bot profiles, combined with a specific and credible account-deletion complaint, are serious enough that we'd want you to know about both before signing up, not after. If you do, document your cancellation and be ready to dispute charges directly with your card issuer if the platform's own process falls short.