Editorial review · Updated September 2026
BeNaughty
BeNaughty is a Together Networks property — free and fully functional for women, sign-up-and-browse-only for men until they pay. It has no confirmed data breach on record, which puts it ahead of several platforms in this hub on that front. But its current Trustpilot score (1.6/5 from 636 reviews) is genuinely bad, and the $2.99 trial that converts into $57.13/month if you forget to cancel is one of the steeper jumps we've seen.
Platform Details
Pros & Cons
+ What works
- ✓Free and fully functional (including messaging) for women
- ✓No independently confirmed data breach found, unlike several other platforms in this hub
- ✓Notably specific LGBTQ role-selection options (Top/Versatile/Bottom/Versatop/Versabottom) for gay male matching
! What to watch
- •Real, serious current Trustpilot record: 1.6/5 from 636 reviews, dominated by fake-profile and unauthorized-billing complaints
- •Steep trial-to-full-price jump: a $2.99 three-day trial converts into $57.13 for a full month if not cancelled in time
- •Men get no free messaging at all — sign-up and browsing only
- •Part of a large multi-site network (Together Networks, 300+ properties) — some complaint patterns may reflect shared backend issues across sister sites, not BeNaughty specifically
Community Consensus
"Multiple Reddit threads (r/DatingApps, r/DatingHelp) are literally titled asking whether BeNaughty is a scam — sentiment is skeptical, centered on the free-to-join, pay-to-message model and how many messages come from apparently automated or low-effort accounts."
- Trustpilot
- 1.6 / 5
- 636 reviews
- Company
- IDALIA LIMITED
- Based in
- Ireland
- Typical age
- 18-78
If you're not satisfied with their response, you can request a refund, and they will ensure it's processed.
BeNaughty uses automatic renewal by default. Trial offers convert to recurring memberships unless cancelled before the next billing cycle; cancel ideally at least 3 days before renewal to avoid being charged again.
A real, large network brand with a rough current reputation — and a trial-to-full-price jump steep enough to catch people off guard.
BeNaughty is a Together Networks property — free and fully functional for women, sign-up-and-browse-only for men until they pay. It has no confirmed data breach on record, which puts it ahead of several platforms in this hub on that front. But its current Trustpilot score (1.6/5 from 636 reviews) is genuinely bad, and the $2.99 trial that converts into $57.13/month if you forget to cancel is one of the steeper jumps we've seen.
Score breakdown
We give real credit for the absence of a confirmed breach and for genuinely free full access for women. But current Trustpilot sentiment and a pricing structure that makes it easy to get charged far more than you expected both pull the score down meaningfully.
Explicit hookup framing, plus unusually specific role-selection options for gay male matching.
Part of Together Networks (300+ dating sites, ~9.5M new users/month across the whole portfolio) — real scale, though not independently verifiable per-brand.
1.6/5 from 636 reviews — fake-profile and unauthorized-charge complaints dominate.
No independently confirmed data breach found — genuinely better than several other platforms in this hub on this specific point.
Fully free and functional (including messaging) for women; men get browsing only.
A $2.99, 3-day trial jumps to $57.13 for a full month if you don't cancel in time — a steep, easy-to-miss cliff.
✓ Best For
- •Women, who get free, fully functional access including messaging
- •People specifically looking for gay male matching with granular role-selection options (Top/Versatile/Bottom and variants)
- •Anyone who weighs the absence of a confirmed data breach heavily — BeNaughty has a cleaner record here than several competitors
- •Users comfortable with a straightforward sign-up-free, pay-to-message model for men
✕ Not For
- •Men hoping for any free messaging — there's no path to contacting someone without paying
- •Anyone who might forget to cancel a trial — the jump from $2.99 to $57.13/month is one of the steepest we've documented in this hub
- •People who weight current independent reputation heavily — a 1.6/5 Trustpilot score from 636 reviews is a real, current signal
- •Anyone specifically avoiding large multi-brand networks where backend issues can span sister sites
What BeNaughty Actually Is
BeNaughty is operated by IDALIA LIMITED out of Dublin, Ireland, and is a trademark of Together Networks Holdings Limited — a large operator that, by its own account, runs more than 300 dating properties across 40 countries, including well-known names like Flirt.com, WildBuddies.com, and NaughtyDate.com. The BeNaughty trademark itself was filed back in 2009, putting it among the longer-running brands in this hub even if the exact launch date of the current site isn't independently documented.
The pitch is straightforward: casual, no-strings hookup matching with cross-gender and same-sex support. One detail worth noting — BeNaughty offers unusually specific role-selection options for gay male matching (Top, Versatile, Bottom, Versatop, Versabottom), a level of granularity most general-purpose hookup platforms don't bother with.
Real Pricing Breakdown
BeNaughty runs the same gender-differentiated model as several other platforms in this hub: women get free access, including messaging, at no cost. Men can sign up, browse, and build a profile for free, but need a paid plan to message anyone.
Here's the part that deserves its own callout: the entry point for men is a $2.99, 3-day trial. If you don't cancel before it ends, it converts into a full month at $57.13 — nearly 20 times the trial price. That's one of the steeper trial-to-full-price jumps we've documented anywhere in this project, and it's the kind of gap that catches people who signed up 'just to look' off guard.
| Plan | Price and billing | Monthly |
|---|---|---|
| Women — standard access | Free | Full access, including messaging |
| Men — 3-day trial | $2.99 · One-time, auto-renews after | Trial rate |
| Men — 1 month | $57.13 · Billed monthly | $57.13/mo |
| Men — 3 months | ~$85.70 · Billed every 3 months | $28.57/mo |
| Men — 6 months | ~$114.27 · Billed every 6 months | $19.05/mo |
The Trust Problem, and What We Could Not Confirm
BeNaughty carries a 1.6-out-of-5 Trustpilot score from 636 reviews — a real, current signal, not a historic footnote. The dominant complaints mirror what we've seen across several platforms in this hub: profiles that look automated or AI-generated, unauthorized or unexpected recurring charges, and difficulty reaching support for cancellations or refunds. A minority of reviewers described the setup process as easy and a 'Safe Mode' feature (restricting contact to verified members only) as genuinely useful.
We looked specifically for a confirmed data breach and didn't find one from a credible source. One low-credibility security-monitoring site referenced an alleged leak without independent confirmation from Have I Been Pwned or reputable outlets, so we're not reporting it as fact — but we also can't rule it out. On the information available, BeNaughty's breach record looks cleaner than AdultFriendFinder's or Fling.com's, and that's worth crediting even while the Trustpilot numbers stay a real concern.
Ready to see who's active near you?
Try BeNaughty Free →Being Part of a Large Network Cuts Both Ways
Together Networks operates BeNaughty alongside hundreds of other dating sites sharing infrastructure and, likely, backend systems. That scale is a real asset for liquidity. But it also means some of the fake-profile and billing complaints reported for BeNaughty may reflect systemic issues shared across the wider network rather than something unique to this specific brand — worth keeping in mind if you also encounter similar complaints about a sister site like Flirt.com or NaughtyDate.com.
Frequently asked questions
BeNaughty is a real, established brand with one genuine advantage over several other platforms in this hub: we couldn't find a confirmed data breach in its history. It also delivers on free, full access for women. But its current Trustpilot record (1.6/5) is a real and recent signal worth taking seriously, and the trial-to-full-price jump for men is steep enough that it deserves its own warning. If you go in aware of both, and you cancel the trial promptly if you're just testing it, there's a legitimate, long-running platform here — just not one with a clean bill of health on independent reputation.