Editor's Review General Dating Hub General / Mainstream General / Mainstream Dating

Plenty of Fish

Plenty of Fish (POF) has been around since 2003, is now part of Match Group, and claims the single largest member base of any platform in this hub — 150 million and counting. Its real differentiator is that it still lets you message freely without paying, which almost no major competitor does anymore. It's a legacy product and it shows — the interface and match quality draw real, consistent complaints — but for sheer reach and a genuinely free core experience, it's still one of the biggest names in mainstream dating.

Full platform description

Plenty of Fish is a free dating service that enables users to date, chat, and match with other members. The platform operates with a cookie-based system to maintain core functionality, including user authentication and preference storage. Performance tracking allows the site to monitor traffic patterns and user behavior to optimize the experience and identify popular features. Advertising cookies measure campaign effectiveness and deliver more relevant ads to users, though users retain the ability to opt out of targeted advertising and personal information sharing for marketing purposes under applicable US privacy regulations.

Editor score 5.7 / 10
Price Free to join
Members (est.) 150M+ View source
Trustpilot 1.7 ★ 52 647 reviews

Platform Details

iOS App Android App 🎥 Video Chat ✓ Email Verification✓ Age Verification (18+) 🌐 13 Languages Network: match group

Pros & Cons

+ What works

  • ✓Free messaging
  • ✓Large user base
  • ✓Detailed profiles
  • ✓Comprehensive search filters
  • ✓Email verification and optional photo validation
  • ✓Block and report suspicious profiles

! What to watch

  • •Outdated interface
  • •Abundance of fake profiles
  • •Overwhelming number of low-quality matches
  • •Hidden information for non-upgraded users

Community Consensus

Reddit Summary

"Mixed reviews on Reddit; some users say it's terrible, others say it's okay, but generally negative sentiment. Some users question how it's still running."

Trustpilot
1.7 / 5
52 647 reviews
App Store
4.3 / 5
1 807 839 ratings
Google Play
3.7 / 5
354 070 ratings
Company
Plentyoffish Media ULC
Based in
Canada
Founded
[object Object]
Typical age
18+
Refund Policy

14-day full refund under local law for EU/EEA/UK/Switzerland; otherwise non-refundable.

Auto-Renewal

Subscription automatically renews unless auto-renew is turned off at least 24 hours before the end of the current period.

The BestPolyDating editorial review

The largest claimed member base of any app in this hub (150M+) built on a rare, still-honest promise: messaging that's actually free.

Plenty of Fish (POF) has been around since 2003, is now part of Match Group, and claims the single largest member base of any platform in this hub — 150 million and counting. Its real differentiator is that it still lets you message freely without paying, which almost no major competitor does anymore. It's a legacy product and it shows — the interface and match quality draw real, consistent complaints — but for sheer reach and a genuinely free core experience, it's still one of the biggest names in mainstream dating.

5.7
out of 10, editorial score
Visit Plenty of Fish
This is a research-based editorial analysis — built from public pricing pages, App Store & Play Store data, security disclosures, and aggregated Reddit/Trustpilot sentiment. It is not a hands-on test (we did not create an account or exchange messages). See our full methodology for what that distinction means.

Score breakdown

Weighted most heavily toward brand recognition and scale — POF's 20+ years of operation and claimed 150M-member base — while still factoring its Trustpilot standing, security history, and dated interface into the final number.

Brand Recognition & Scale 7.5

Claims 150 million members — the largest figure of any platform in this hub — with over 1.8M App Store reviews and 20+ years of continuous operation as part of Match Group.

Feature Depth & Positioning 5.5

A genuinely free-first model is the real differentiator here — full messaging without a paid tier — but the interface and matching experience feel dated next to newer entrants in this hub.

Trust & Reputation Signals 2.5

Trustpilot currently shows 1.7/5 from over 52,000 reviews — the largest review sample of any platform in this entire hub — with recurring complaints about fake profiles and matches outside stated search preferences.

Security Track Record 5.0

A widely reported 2011 breach exposed member usernames and passwords, and a separate, undated researcher disclosure found first names and postal codes exposed via the mobile app API. No confirmed incident has been reported in the last several years.

Pricing Transparency 7.0

Genuinely free full messaging is rare among major dating apps at this scale. Optional Premium tiers are clearly structured by commitment length, typically landing somewhere in the $10-$23/month range depending on term.

✓ Best For

  • •Anyone who wants to message freely without hitting a paywall — one of the only major apps left that still allows this
  • •Users who want the largest claimed member pool in this hub and don't mind a more dated interface
  • •People comparison-shopping other Match Group brands who want the free-tier alternative to Tinder or Match

✕ Not For

  • •Anyone who wants a modern, polished interface over sheer member volume
  • •Users who want the tightest possible signal-to-noise ratio — the free model draws a higher volume of inactive and low-effort profiles
01

What Plenty of Fish Actually Is Today

Plenty of Fish launched in 2003 and was acquired by Match Group in 2015 for $575 million, making it a sibling brand to Tinder, Match.com, Hinge, and OkCupid under the same corporate umbrella. What's kept it relevant for over two decades is a simple, still-rare promise: you can build a profile, browse, and message other members without paying anything. At a time when most major competitors gate real conversation behind a subscription, that's a genuine structural difference, not a marketing footnote.

The platform supports detailed profiles and comprehensive search filters, along with the basics you'd expect from a Match Group property — email verification, optional photo validation, and standard block/report tools. It claims 150 million members, the largest figure of any platform reviewed in this hub, and its App Store footprint (over 1.8 million reviews) backs up that it's still one of the most-downloaded dating apps in the category.

02

What to Know Before You Sign Up

In the interest of a complete picture: POF's current Trustpilot page shows 1.7 out of 5 from more than 52,000 reviews — the largest review sample of any platform in this entire hub, which itself says something about how many people have passed through the app over the years. The most consistent complaints are about fake or inactive profiles and the search algorithm surfacing matches outside stated location or preference settings, alongside a genuinely dated interface that several reviewers compare unfavorably to newer apps.

On security: a 2011 breach, reported at the time by security researchers, exposed member usernames and passwords — this predates Match Group's 2015 acquisition of the platform. A separate, undated researcher disclosure also found that first names and postal codes could be exposed through the mobile app's API. We haven't found a confirmed security incident reported in the last several years, which is a comparatively cleaner recent record than some sibling Match Group brands.

Frequently asked questions

Is Plenty of Fish (POF) legit?

Yes — it's a Match Group-owned platform operating continuously since 2003, with a claimed 150 million members, the largest figure of any app in this hub. Its current Trustpilot score (1.7/5) runs lower than we'd like, with fake-profile and preference-matching complaints being the most common themes — worth knowing, though Trustpilot samples for major dating apps skew negative across the board.

Is Plenty of Fish really free?

Yes, in a way most major competitors no longer match — core functions including full messaging are free. Optional Premium tiers add extras like seeing who's viewed your profile, typically priced in the $10-$23/month range depending on how long a term you commit to.

Has Plenty of Fish had a data breach?

Yes — a 2011 breach exposed member usernames and passwords, predating its 2015 acquisition by Match Group. A separate researcher disclosure also found first names and postal codes exposed via the app's API. No confirmed incident has been reported in the last several years.

Is Plenty of Fish owned by Match Group?

Yes — Match Group acquired POF in 2015 for $575 million, making it a sibling brand to Tinder, Match.com, Hinge, and OkCupid.

Bottom line

Plenty of Fish earns its place in this hub on the strength of two things few competitors can match: the largest claimed member base of any platform reviewed here, and a genuinely free core messaging experience at a scale almost nothing else in the category still offers. It has real, worth-knowing issues — a rough current Trustpilot record, a dated interface, and an old but real breach on the books — and we're naming all of them directly. But for sheer reach and an honestly free entry point, it remains one of the biggest names in mainstream dating.

Visit Plenty of Fish → BestPolyDating Editorial Team · Updated September 2026
Visit Plenty of Fish — Free to Join →