Editor's Review General Dating Hub Elite Matchmaking Elite Matchmaking

It's Just Lunch

It's Just Lunch, founded in 1991, arranges lunch or after-work drinks with matches picked by a personal matchmaker, across 200+ US cities. Trustpilot shows 3.1/5 from 707 reviews, with staff praised and matching quality, slow responses and cost criticised. Memberships typically cost $2,000–$4,000 and the fees are nonrefundable.

Full platform description

It's Just Lunch operates as a professional matchmaking service targeting busy professionals who prefer personalized dating guidance over app-based matching. The core service model centers on arranging face-to-face lunch dates or after-work drinks, which the company positions as the ideal format for assessing chemistry between potential partners. The process begins with an initial consultation where professional matchmakers gather detailed information about each client's profession, interests, lifestyle, and relationship objectives. Matchmakers then use a combination of intuition and client preferences to hand-select matches, honoring stated criteria regarding age, religion, and parental status. The company manages all date logistics, including restaurant reservations and scheduling, positioning itself as a dating concierge that eliminates the administrative burden of traditional online dating. A key differentiator is the emphasis on privacy and confidentiality. Unlike app-based platforms, It's Just Lunch does not maintain public profiles or require clients to engage in swiping or messaging. The company maintains selective membership standards, accepting only clients it believes can be successfully matched rather than pursuing a high-volume user acquisition model. The service spans 200+ cities across the United States and reports 10,000+ success stories alongside 500+ five-star client reviews. The company provides supplementary dating advice through blog content and matchmaker-authored articles addressing topics such as first impression techniques, conversation strategies, and compatibility factors. It's Just Lunch frames itself as a premium alternative to algorithmic matching, emphasizing the role of human judgment and personalized service in identifying compatible partners.

Editor score 5.1 / 10
Price Not published
Members (est.) Not published
Trustpilot 3.1 ★ 707 reviews

Platform Details

✓ Email Verification✓ Age Verification (18+)

Pros & Cons

+ What works

  • ✓Saves time compared to apps
  • ✓Personalized introductions
  • ✓More serious daters
  • ✓Privacy-focused process
  • ✓Professional matchmakers

! What to watch

  • •High membership pricing
  • •Slower-than-apps process
  • •Inconsistent quality across locations
  • •Multiple lawsuits
  • •Complaints about ignored criteria

Community Consensus

Reddit Summary

"Reddit users report mixed experiences; some praise the personalized service and professional matchmakers, but many complain about high costs, mismatches, difficulty canceling, and refund issues. Some even label it a scam."

Trustpilot
3.1 / 5
707 reviews
Company
It's Just Lunch
Based in
USA
Typical age
25-50
Refund Policy

If you cancel, It's Just Lunch will return, within ten days of the date on which you gave notice of cancellation, any payments you have made.

Auto-Renewal

Subscription will not automatically renew.

The BestPolyDating editorial review

The longest-running matchmaker in this hub, with a mixed record and a nonrefundable price.

It's Just Lunch, founded in 1991, arranges lunch or after-work drinks with matches picked by a personal matchmaker, across 200+ US cities. Trustpilot shows 3.1/5 from 707 reviews, with staff praised and matching quality, slow responses and cost criticised. Memberships typically cost $2,000–$4,000 and the fees are nonrefundable.

5.1
out of 10, editorial score
Visit It's Just Lunch
This is a research-based editorial analysis — built from public pricing pages, App Store & Play Store data, security disclosures, and aggregated Reddit/Trustpilot sentiment. It is not a hands-on test (we did not create an account or exchange messages). See our full methodology for what that distinction means.

Score breakdown

Weighted toward its long history and approachable lunch-date format, balanced against a mixed Trustpilot record, BBB complaints about sales tactics and nonrefundable fees.

Brand Recognition & Scale 7.0

Founded in 1991 and present in 200+ US cities; the longest track record of any matchmaker we reviewed.

Feature Depth & Positioning 5.5

Matchmakers hand-pick matches, schedule the restaurant and date, and keep no public profiles. Reviewers say matches often miss stated criteria.

Trust & Reputation Signals 4.5

Trustpilot shows 3.1/5 from 707 reviews (43% five-star, 29% one-star). The BBB lists 19 complaints in three years, mostly about sales pressure and refunds.

Security Track Record 5.5

We found no data breach or security incident on record.

Pricing Transparency 4.0

Third-party sources put typical memberships at $2,000–$4,000, depending on location and number of dates. Fees are nonrefundable.

✓ Best For

  • •Busy professionals who want a low-tech, in-person-first format
  • •People who prefer a matchmaker to any kind of profile browsing

✕ Not For

  • •Anyone who wants a refund option
  • •Users who want strict control over who they are matched with
01

The Short Version

It's Just Lunch launched in 1991 and now operates in more than 200 US cities. The pitch is simple: a matchmaker learns your profession, interests and relationship goals, chooses matches and handles the logistics, so all you do is turn up for lunch or after-work drinks. There are no public profiles and no swiping.

In the interest of a complete picture: Trustpilot shows 3.1 out of 5 from 707 reviews. Clients praise attentive staff, but the recurring complaints are matches that ignore stated criteria (distance, age, lifestyle), slow replies from coordinators, and the cost relative to results. The Better Business Bureau lists 19 complaints over three years, mostly about high-pressure sales, misleading membership details and refund or cancellation problems. Third-party sources put typical memberships at $2,000–$4,000, and the fees are nonrefundable.

Frequently asked questions

Is It's Just Lunch legit?

Yes. It has operated since 1991 and is real, with many satisfied clients, but its 3.1/5 Trustpilot score and BBB complaints about sales tactics and refunds are worth reading first.

How much does It's Just Lunch cost?

The company does not publish prices. Third-party sources put typical memberships at $2,000–$4,000, depending on location and number of dates, and membership fees are nonrefundable.

What is the It's Just Lunch process?

A matchmaker interviews you, selects matches, books the restaurant and schedules the date. After each date you give feedback that shapes later matches.

Bottom line

It's Just Lunch has more history than any other matchmaker here and a simple, appealing format. A mixed record and nonrefundable fees mean you should ask about exact terms and match criteria before you pay.

Visit It's Just Lunch → BestPolyDating Editorial Team · Updated September 2026
Visit It's Just Lunch — Free to Join →